Looks pink... majority here are saying she's a blue or blue copper so I was wrong (apologies...🙂)
On the plus side you got another Marans and more chocolate eggs hopefully. 😃
That sounds like typical laying schedule for 5 layers (4-5 eggs/week per layer) at peak.
I've got 2 broodys also right now. My first with 2 at the same time. One went last year and the other the year before, but this year they decided to go broody at the same time. 🙂
That's great news... I've heard others say that their birds will go thru that Henhouse Reserve and pick out all the goodies and leave the rest. Where your all-flock and layer feed is complete.
This is hearsay tho... I'm just spreading info.
Just throwing it out there.
If you have the space and can afford them. Get all 4. Then decide in a month or so. (Longer the better), and re-home or sell the boy you don't want. That gives you time to watch them fill out and color up.... 🤨
Big and chunky, low to the ground not tall in the legs. Wide stance. If there's any color on the boys look for too much in the chest area but that's not too important, it may molt out. Look for pink feet, and feathered legs but not too much and only on the outside of leg shanks and outer toe...
If there's 4 birds I see 2 cockerels, 2 pullets.
1st pic... 3 birds. Cockerel on left, 2 pullets. Can't see head of 4th.
2nd pic.... 4 birds- left to right. Pullet, looks like a cockerel, pullet, barely see head and comb but it's a cockerel.
3rd pic. Left to right. Only 2 in that pic
Pullet and...
My birds didn't like pellets, also. But I had quite a bit of it. So I started mixing it in with the crumble adding more every couple days til it was 100%.
They now eat it.
You've gotten a lot of great advise so far. I can add go low and slow. Chickens are a prey animal and most everything deadly comes from above. Get as low as possible and scoop them up from underneath. Grabbing them from above is scary.
Depending on your weather if it's warm enough, you could...