eight and a half weeks and down one

[Nic]

Ah well, I guess I keep waiting for an egg or a crow then, no definitive answer - well defintive answers but no consensus

Isn't it to do with shape of the bird aswell as combs and wattles?

 

[Frozen Feathers]

I think if they were roos their backs be more of V shape rather then the U shape yours have. Their combs also appear to be yellow at the tops and s roo would have a vibrant red comb. The black Star has to be female, no question about that one. Maybe you just have better feed in the UK, and that can make quite a size difference, or better genes, who knows, but if speckledhen thinks they are girls...I'm on her side

 

[Nic]

Thanks Angie

Yep the combs are quite yellowey in places and definitely more pinky still than bright red. Nice to hear Wobble (black one) is a hen too although we might need to think about getting a rooster now which seems an odd idea after worrying about having four of them