Black majesty maran laying BLUE?

JuniperGreen

In the Brooder
Feb 2, 2025
8
10
24
Canada
Hi! I'll probably make an introduction thread another time, but today we're so confused that I had to do this one first.

We got 3 chicks (EE, olive egger, black maran) last year for the first time. Neither my husband or I had any previous exp, though I have had many types of animals my whole life including birds. We figured it out as we went (with a lot of info from backyard chickens!! :))
All three chicks grew up fine, except my EE who ended up showing cross beak about at about a week old. We've been hand feeding and she's gained weight/started laying.

So anyway. My olive egger has been been consistently laying since about 7 mon old, almost every day, and they are, surprise, olive green. About two weeks after, my EE has been laying and hers are consistently pink (tho her first was kind of orange). We have been waiting for my maran to lay a brown egg, and last week she starting going SPLOOT! So we knew it was coming.


Now I'm at work this week, my husband tells me he saw our olive egger lay, took the egg, then a couple hours later a blue egg showed up. I was super surprised, and was googling everything about EE, seeing posts elluding possible liver problems with egg colour changes, etc. I heard a few stories about EE laying suddenly diff eggs, but this seemed extreme. The eggshell also was thick and bumpy, hers are always perfect.

I eventually just figured she had an off day, and would monitor. Next day she laid pink again. Okay. Now today, I go out in the morning. The olive egger is out of the coop, the other two are inside. They come out when they hear me. I look in, and there behold, two warm eggs. One pink and one blue.

Therefore I have no other leads. It's got to be my maran. I have not seen this discussed anywhere yet, but I'm looking for an answer. Do ppl cross marans with anything else? Could it be a dietary issue? She is a very picky eater even with treats. I don't know if I should be concerned!

Pictures attached.
 

Attachments

  • IMG-20250118-WA0012.jpg
    IMG-20250118-WA0012.jpg
    499.1 KB · Views: 51
  • IMG-20250118-WA0020.jpg
    IMG-20250118-WA0020.jpg
    573.8 KB · Views: 18
  • IMG-20250202-WA0017.jpg
    IMG-20250202-WA0017.jpg
    598.5 KB · Views: 23
  • Messenger_creation_D8E7AFE4-3087-4A86-BC39-BCE6F530E945.png
    Messenger_creation_D8E7AFE4-3087-4A86-BC39-BCE6F530E945.png
    1.5 MB · Views: 19
  • Messenger_creation_77EEA3CA-C1C0-404C-BA50-A72D61ECD92E.png
    Messenger_creation_77EEA3CA-C1C0-404C-BA50-A72D61ECD92E.png
    1 MB · Views: 15
Last edited:
Hi!

I've got your answer but I'm not sure you're going to like it.

Your marans is a mix, not a pure bred. The comb type should be straight and it's not and her earlobes are the wrong color. I'm not sure what she's mixed with but I would call her an Easter Egger.

I'd recommend creating a thread under the section "What breed or gender" and see if anyone can identify what breed she's mixed with.

EDIT: I just realized your title says Black Majesty Marans. I was thinking you thought she was a BCM. In that case, majesty marans are meant to be mixes between a BCM and a Plymouth Barred Rock. Both lay brown eggs. Both have straight combs...
 
Hi!

I've got your answer but I'm not sure you're going to like it.

Your marans is a mix, not a pure bred. The comb type should be straight and it's not and her earlobes are the wrong color. I'm not sure what she's mixed with but I would call her an Easter Egger.

I'd recommend creating a thread under the section "What breed or gender" and see if anyone can identify what breed she's mixed with.
Oh! We're totally fine with her not being purebred. We just bought three chicks in different colours, and the lady working the chicks in the store that day wasn't very educated, so she gave us her best guess on what they were. I've assumed this whole time we were waiting for a dark brown egg to appear in the box, and this has thrown us for a whole loop! But we are happy to have a mix breed, as long as shes healthy that's all we worry about! She's our sassiest chicken, the other two are very cuddly, especially my EE. But they all get along with each other very well!
 
Oh! We're totally fine with her not being purebred. We just bought three chicks in different colours, and the lady working the chicks in the store that day wasn't very educated, so she gave us her best guess on what they were. I've assumed this whole time we were waiting for a dark brown egg to appear in the box, and this has thrown us for a whole loop! But we are happy to have a mix breed, as long as shes healthy that's all we worry about! She's our sassiest chicken, the other two are very cuddly, especially my EE. But they all get along with each other very well!
That's great! I'm inclined to say she's the one laying the pinkish brown and your crossbeaked EE is the one laying blue. I would keep a close eye and see if you can actually catch them laying to confirm.
 
That's great! I'm inclined to say she's the one laying the pinkish brown and your crossbeaked EE is the one laying blue. I would keep a close eye and see if you can actually catch them laying to confirm.
Our EE has been laying for about a month already, I also expected blue from her, but we've been seeing (in real time) her laying in the box and taking her eggs since she started, we know the pink are hers.
Trust me, it would make so much more sense to us too, but our 'maran' has been our late bloomer!

Edit: just as I sent this, my Olive Egger is out now in the box laying. So then all three have laid today :lol:
 
Last edited:
Our EE has been laying for about a month already, I also expected blue from her, but we've been seeing (in real time) her laying in the box and taking her eggs since she started, we know the pink are hers.
Trust me, it would make so much more sense to us too, but our 'maran' has been our late bloomer!

Edit: just as I sent this, my Olive Egger is out now in the box laying. So then all three have laid today :lol:
Chickens rarely make sense... 😂
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom