"Pullets" are almost half roosters: a rant

Pukkits

Chirping
5 Years
Sep 26, 2019
26
40
86
Disclaimer: I know sexing day old chicks is as much an art as a science, and is not easy. I also know sexed chicks are only a 90% chance of being the sexed sex. This knowledge does not comfort me at this time. This is an exasperated rant.


Did anyone else get a bunch of little roosters in their "pullets" this year?


We were thinking of taking a chicken break after our sweet aging hens pass (they are both five and still laying). Then the egg crisis, so we decided to get some more hens to provide eggs for us and our extended family. Competition for chicks this year locally was pretty heavy, plus when we got chicks in February there were storms between the hatcheries shipping and the feed stores selling them here. What the stores were supposed to get went out the window and they got what they got. By some luck, we managed to get our Orpingtons, though for some reason no buffs were available so we ended up with lavender and chocolate. I watched them being unpacked, so I know they were day old and saw they were labeled "pullets".


The lavenders grew like little mutants and are huge for their age. And it has become apparent they were straight run, as 3 of the 6 appear to be roosters. We had to separate the males, as they kept herding the females away from us, and telling them we are scary and panicking everyone. After moving the males, I have the females eating treats from my hands in just a few days. And the males aren't afraid of me anymore either. I assume this was a protection behavior and with no girls they are just chilling in their bachelor pen.


The chocolates, one week younger, are only two thirds the size and are separated from the lavender girls by mesh to prevent bullying. This morning I saw one of them is getting a rather puffy chest (the lavender males have noticably puffier chests than the females) and some very red wattles. It's also the one that loves to jump up and perch on the edge of the pen when I lift the mesh lid to take care of their needs. Now I'm starting to worry that more of the chocolates might be yet more roosters. I'll be heartbroken if my favorite absurdly friendly Pudding is a rooster too.


Most mail order chicks were sold out this spring, as well as I was seeing about $75 in shipping. At this point, I'd pay the extra to actually have better sexed pullets next time we buy chicks. People that mail ordered your chicks, did you find the sexing more accurate?


It's not even the cost of the birds, the feed and housing lost when sexing is this level of unreliable. Almost half the chicks we got appear to be roosters, so how can we plan for our needed egg layers? And I'm stressing on what to do with the roosters. While I eat chicken, I'm not really capable of processing my own. Thankfully the roosters are all getting along so far, but the larger they get the more I'm going to struggle to house them, as it's apparent they have to be separated if I'm going to have friendly hens.


Thank you for listening to my rant. What have your experiences been this year on "pullets"?


And if anyone in Oregon wants lavender and possibly chocolate Orpington roosters, let me know.
 
Disclaimer: I know sexing day old chicks is as much an art as a science, and is not easy. I also know sexed chicks are only a 90% chance of being the sexed sex. This knowledge does not comfort me at this time. This is an exasperated rant.


Did anyone else get a bunch of little roosters in their "pullets" this year?


We were thinking of taking a chicken break after our sweet aging hens pass (they are both five and still laying). Then the egg crisis, so we decided to get some more hens to provide eggs for us and our extended family. Competition for chicks this year locally was pretty heavy, plus when we got chicks in February there were storms between the hatcheries shipping and the feed stores selling them here. What the stores were supposed to get went out the window and they got what they got. By some luck, we managed to get our Orpingtons, though for some reason no buffs were available so we ended up with lavender and chocolate. I watched them being unpacked, so I know they were day old and saw they were labeled "pullets".


The lavenders grew like little mutants and are huge for their age. And it has become apparent they were straight run, as 3 of the 6 appear to be roosters. We had to separate the males, as they kept herding the females away from us, and telling them we are scary and panicking everyone. After moving the males, I have the females eating treats from my hands in just a few days. And the males aren't afraid of me anymore either. I assume this was a protection behavior and with no girls they are just chilling in their bachelor pen.


The chocolates, one week younger, are only two thirds the size and are separated from the lavender girls by mesh to prevent bullying. This morning I saw one of them is getting a rather puffy chest (the lavender males have noticably puffier chests than the females) and some very red wattles. It's also the one that loves to jump up and perch on the edge of the pen when I lift the mesh lid to take care of their needs. Now I'm starting to worry that more of the chocolates might be yet more roosters. I'll be heartbroken if my favorite absurdly friendly Pudding is a rooster too.


Most mail order chicks were sold out this spring, as well as I was seeing about $75 in shipping. At this point, I'd pay the extra to actually have better sexed pullets next time we buy chicks. People that mail ordered your chicks, did you find the sexing more accurate?


It's not even the cost of the birds, the feed and housing lost when sexing is this level of unreliable. Almost half the chicks we got appear to be roosters, so how can we plan for our needed egg layers? And I'm stressing on what to do with the roosters. While I eat chicken, I'm not really capable of processing my own. Thankfully the roosters are all getting along so far, but the larger they get the more I'm going to struggle to house them, as it's apparent they have to be separated if I'm going to have friendly hens.


Thank you for listening to my rant. What have your experiences been this year on "pullets"?


And if anyone in Oregon wants lavender and possibly chocolate Orpington roosters, let me know.
I just made a similar post. 🤷‍♀️ It must be an issue.

I’m starting a new flock after not having chickens for many years. Not only has it been difficult for me to get my hands on chicks. I have 8 chicks at 3 weeks, assuming at least 4 are roosters so far. Bought 3 at the farm store, 2 weeks old now and suspecting 2 of those are roosters. Then bought 5 more from a breeder and those are yet to be determined. 1 Easter Egger I hope is a pullet.
 
I'm curious about this . . .if you buy sexed chicks direct from a hatchery do you get your money back, or a chick of the correct sex if it isn't?
 
So sorry this has been your experience.

We usually get what we ask for, but here's my strategy when ordering from a hatchery: I order a certain number of pullets, and also a certain number of cockerels, of either the same or a different breed. Since ordering this way, I always get exactly what I order. Imagine that! So for example I might order half a dozen EE pullets and half a dozen CornishX cockerels.

I don't process our meaties, either. City girl, no experience, tried it, did badly. Now I hire it done at $2/ bird, well worth it. I haul live birds to my lady that does it in the morning, pick up birds ready to refrigerate in the afternoon. Three or four days in the fridge, then down to the freezer they go. Next!
 
So sorry this has been your experience.

We usually get what we ask for, but here's my strategy when ordering from a hatchery: I order a certain number of pullets, and also a certain number of cockerels, of either the same or a different breed. Since ordering this way, I always get exactly what I order. Imagine that! So for example I might order half a dozen EE pullets and half a dozen CornishX cockerels.

I don't process our meaties, either. City girl, no experience, tried it, did badly. Now I hire it done at $2/ bird, well worth it. I haul live birds to my lady that does it in the morning, pick up birds ready to refrigerate in the afternoon. Three or four days in the fridge, then down to the freezer they go. Next!
At what age do you process the boys?
 
So sorry this has been your experience.

We usually get what we ask for, but here's my strategy when ordering from a hatchery: I order a certain number of pullets, and also a certain number of cockerels, of either the same or a different breed. Since ordering this way, I always get exactly what I order. Imagine that! So for example I might order half a dozen EE pullets and half a dozen CornishX cockerels.

I don't process our meaties, either. City girl, no experience, tried it, did badly. Now I hire it done at $2/ bird, well worth it. I haul live birds to my lady that does it in the morning, pick up birds ready to refrigerate in the afternoon. Three or four days in the fridge, then down to the freezer they go. Next!
This sounds like a really good system. Unfortunately our local butchers have pretty big minimum on chickens (they require like 30 plus birds) that I don't have space to start. I know someone who will take excess roosters to process for himself as a way to get rid of them, but I tend to be sentimental about the chicks we raise. I'd probably do better about being sentimental if we raised more at once and it was less personal contact. It certainly would be nice to stock our freezer. Treasure your processor person, they sound great.
 
Update: I found a rooster a home! I posted the boys on the neighborhood forum and a lady contacted me. Their rooster died a few weeks ago and they were looking for a new roo. Our young chickens have been in the garage brooder with no contact with our birds, so she was pleased she didn't need to be as concerned about bringing something home with him. The boys were very charming and she took the lad that politely took some oats from her hand. He's off to a home with 13 hens.

One down, hopefully only a few more to go. I just need more of that kind of neighbor to message me.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom