I really like these birds. My birds are over a year old now, and I have been very happy with them so far. Neither of my hens have ever gone broody which is good because I sure do not need any more broodies. They also do not sing the "I just laid and egg song" which is nice. I am not sure if "quiet" is common for this breed but that has been my experience. I have hatched lots of chicks and they are always super strong and healthy. People who visit the ranch often comment that they are "cute" instead of beautiful. I think they are both.