You are quite right.I also believe that before Shadrach began taking care of the allotment chickens, the coop was in such a state and what's more overpopulation was such a problem that broodiness was just too risky. I don't think it's comparable to your situation, @BDutch. The allotment chickens didn't have enough to eat and crammed on the floor to roost. A hen couldn't have stocked up on food before sitting and she would have had no way to feed her chicks correctly.
Letting Fret sit again is an interesting choice. Is it ok health wise for a hen to sit twice with so short a break, or are you taking this option only because of the specific situation of Henry and his hens ?
Long term for a chicken isn't the same number of years as long term for a man. I certainly hope you get to see the next generation of allotment chickens and while I wish Henry a long life, I also hope you'll get to see his successor.
Any update on your move ?
When Shad started to look after the chickens the situation was so sad. I’m still happy he took/takes the time to look after the chickens despite the stupid neglect and decisions of mrs. C.
My bantams do have a very good life compared to the allotment crowd Shad started with.