Well you ask for honesty - and I breed chickens for eggs not to show - but awile back someone posted either here or on the old BYC a picture of a 'real' show BR. Looked nothing like my hatchery BRs. The barring was picture perfect. Maybe Cyn remembers where to find the link. Your chicks look just like my hatchery stock. I think they're fine examples (LOL or else mine wouldn't be) but I don't know about show birds.