You are right...semantics. Everyone has their own definition. Just like, what do you consider a big breeder? Anyone that raises more than 2 - 3 litters a year, in my opinion is not doing it for the love of the breed..but, that is my opinion. That's why blanket statements should not be used.
2 litters a year with the same female dog is very cruel in my opinion. That is over breeding.
If they are show dogs and have a few female dogs bred in the same year is fine. Make sure it's not a puppy mill either.
My parents bred once every 2-5 years. Not often and always champion dogs. They did their best to improve the breed. They always had hips and knees approved by the vet as well.
Last edited: