pol pullets and hens around here no no cheaper than 10 bucks each, and yeah, I've been burned by the Amish before too - and I've had great luck with them - it isn't that they are or are not Amish - there are sneaky folks everywhere.
I once got a trio of chickens (for 17 bucks) from some Amish folks - both pullets died before the week was out. They weren't sick, really, just weren't healthy from hatch. They had some genetic defect that I was too inexperienced to notice.
Then I got 6 laying hens for 8 bucks each from another Amish gentleman - I love these hens, they lay great (never stopped laying even when I brought them home). You just have to know who you're buying from and never assume because they are "Amish" or "Christian" or some other supposed good folk that they are honest people.
meri