Updated: Cumberland Slider Turtle Help

This is a species of aquatic turtle I feel differently about. Here is a hatchling musk turtle I confiscated off of a kid trying to sell in the park one summer (Had a bucket with 5 I confiscated!)... They stay small (4 inches - 5 tops) and are much easier to care for. Eastern Musk Turtle Hatchling.jpg
 
I agree with Overo Mare, sliders are very tricky pets! They are time consuming and a mess, and will need a very large tank once they are older, as they grow BIG.

That being said, I had a red eared slider for around 10 years, had him since he was about the size of yours. As much of a hassle he was, he was one of my favorite pets! They are incredibly inquisitive, and just so fun to watch!

If you plan to keep adorable little Tilly, I would start him in a 20gal long type tank. At this age, it is best to have the water portion of the tank just deep enough that they can touch the bottom with their back feet, and stick their heads up to breathe. This takes away any risk of accidental drownings in a deep tank (unusual, but does happen when they get way too tired). You will also need a float dock (sold at pet stores) or build a partial area of dry land on one side of the tank. He will need a place to get out of the water under a heat lamp and dry off.

Biggest thing I tell people who want an aquatic turtle is FILTRATION. Get the best filters you can afford, as these guys POOP a LOT. Also get bigger than the rated size is. If the filter says its for a 20 gal, go with the next one up for a 30 gallon. You will need to keep up on the cleaning in his tank. Some people keep it bare (does make cleaning a breeze) but I've never liked the look of a bare tank, so large pebbles are fine too :)

As far as feeding, I would do a base feed of aquatic turtle pellets, and supplement with fish, worms, krill, etc. They will really eat anything they can fit in their mouths, so it is fun to get them treats of random things. Mine absolutely loved cave crickets lol. Feeding fish is also fun, cause some won't get eaten and then you have cute little fish to watch as well!

I would get feeder minnows from the pet store (and the pond, depending on the time of year). I also had luck keeping a large pleco (bottomfeeder catfish) in the tank with him for like 7 years. I loved that fish, lol. I also kept a couple large goldfish with him, but the goldfish will eventually get killed, so don't get too attached!

As far as sexing him goes, you really can't tell externally if he is a male or a female. I think it was maybe a year? Maybe a little more before I could tell what gender mine was. Mine turned out to be a male, and got to be around 10 inches long within the 10 ish year time frame.

Anyway, whatever you decide to do with Tilly, good luck! He is an adorable little dude!
 
Last edited:
@Overo Mare
Awe, what an adorable little guy! I have bounced back and forth about getting another turtle after my slider ran off...yes my indoor pet turtle ran away. While I was cleaning the tank, a cat knocked over the 5 gallon bucket, and out the open door he went on his own grand adventure. I searched out yard and the surrounding woods for HOURS with no luck. That was a very sad day :(

Anyways, I would totally do a musk turtle, little cheaper (set-up wise) and easier to deal with! That one is so cute as well! Did you release those musk turtles you confiscated (Super funny by the way! and really great that you did that! Kids shouldn't be selling them in the park...pretty sure that's illegal at least in my neck of the woods) or did you end up keeping any as pets?
 
Hello friends! I finally remembered to take some pictures after relocating and cleaning Tilly's (maybe Tuttle's) tank. I am finding that I need a submersible heater now as I don't feel like the water is staying warm enough. The temp doesn't seem to fluctuate though. I went back and forth on keeping her and possibly getting a different one (a musk as suggested) and I am such a ridiculous softie, so she's still here. Plus I worry that I have significantly reduced her chances of survival by removing her in the first place. I keep thinking that I've damned this turtles chances for living in the wild, so I need to take the best possible care. I know that this tank won't be sufficient for long and will need to up size, and depending on the sex, I may even need a massive (100 gal+) tank or habitat. With all of that said I'd love to keep Tilly healthy and comfortable. Any chance you have a recommendation on a heater that won't break the bank?

Having trouble uploading pics. Will try again very soon

Thank you all so very much for the replies
 
Spot Tilly!

She loves this fake plant and ALWAYS manages to free it so its free floating and then she "hides" in it very often
20200512_175903.jpg

I am always worried that she'll get herself tangled in it and won't be able to get up for a breath of air. Is this a possible death trap or am I worrying myself over a miniscule risk (I do tend to overreact, most of the time, if I'm being honest)
 
I agree with Overo Mare, sliders are very tricky pets! They are time consuming and a mess, and will need a very large tank once they are older, as they grow BIG.

That being said, I had a red eared slider for around 10 years, had him since he was about the size of yours. As much of a hassle he was, he was one of my favorite pets! They are incredibly inquisitive, and just so fun to watch!

If you plan to keep adorable little Tilly, I would start him in a 20gal long type tank. At this age, it is best to have the water portion of the tank just deep enough that they can touch the bottom with their back feet, and stick their heads up to breathe. This takes away any risk of accidental drownings in a deep tank (unusual, but does happen when they get way too tired). You will also need a float dock (sold at pet stores) or build a partial area of dry land on one side of the tank. He will need a place to get out of the water under a heat lamp and dry off.

Biggest thing I tell people who want an aquatic turtle is FILTRATION. Get the best filters you can afford, as these guys POOP a LOT. Also get bigger than the rated size is. If the filter says its for a 20 gal, go with the next one up for a 30 gallon. You will need to keep up on the cleaning in his tank. Some people keep it bare (does make cleaning a breeze) but I've never liked the look of a bare tank, so large pebbles are fine too :)

As far as feeding, I would do a base feed of aquatic turtle pellets, and supplement with fish, worms, krill, etc. They will really eat anything they can fit in their mouths, so it is fun to get them treats of random things. Mine absolutely loved cave crickets lol. Feeding fish is also fun, cause some won't get eaten and then you have cute little fish to watch as well!

I would get feeder minnows from the pet store (and the pond, depending on the time of year). I also had luck keeping a large pleco (bottomfeeder catfish) in the tank with him for like 7 years. I loved that fish, lol. I also kept a couple large goldfish with him, but the goldfish will eventually get killed, so don't get too attached!

As far as sexing him goes, you really can't tell externally if he is a male or a female. I think it was maybe a year? Maybe a little more before I could tell what gender mine was. Mine turned out to be a male, and got to be around 10 inches long within the 10 ish year time frame.

Anyway, whatever you decide to do with Tilly, good luck! He is an adorable little dude!


I promise that I did read your reply, so thank you for your time and sharing your experience and knowledge. I was worried about the water level being too low, but this makes me feel better! Hopefully if I take some out, the water will be closer to the temp she/he needs. I am so appreciative of this community and the amazing amount of help the members are always so kindly willing to share. Thanks again! Please share any thoughts you may have as I welcome them all, no matter what
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom