I read a bunch about humane killing and it seems there is growing consensus that stunning prior to cutting the throat is the most humane approach.Well. It will really come down to your comfort level as her carer.
-Letting her pass away naturally is the most hands off, but the chook has a drawn out decline. You’d witness the whole decline. Not my cup of tea.
-Benadryl (or most death by drugs) appeals to me in that you get to take a more active role, and it seems quite peaceful. But on the other hand it’s literally watching her pass away for an hour; that’s too much psychological terror for the carer in my opinion, all in an effort to make it seem peaceful. Also requires you to force feed however many pills/liquid to a chook who may not even have an appetite; that’s a source of discomfort on its own.
-Cervical dislocation: a brutal act for the carer, but *immediate*. This option seems like it favors the chooks comfort (being put out of their misery) well over the human’s. It’s what I have opted for in the past.
I would also not trust myself to do cervical dislocation correctly.
So I bought myself a bolt gun which is used for stunning and dispatch of small animals.
I have not had to use it but believe I know how and would do it correctly.
I have had many chicken deaths but they all died naturally either in the coop or in my arms apart from Scary who was my first loss and was taken by a fox.
I think I would only deploy my bolt gun if I believed my chicken was in great distress for example from pain.