Chicken Laying wrong color egg?!

[Chickassan]

They're all yellow on the inside.

 

[SonoranChick]

I am so jealous I used to have some Ameraucanas and I miss those nice blue eggs. But I'm a nerd and consider every egg a little gift...no matter the color. Good luck with your girls, they sure are pretty.

 

[R1V3R20NG]

Well i guess the place i go through for chickens doesn't have any true ameraucanas. i got two there. one lays teal eggs and the other brown eggs. One if them knows how to fly. Its scary. She hasn't tried to leave the yard thankfully. i knew about the egg color check thing but i didn't think it was possible for one to lay a brown egg. here is a pic of the one who flies and lays brown eggs. don't have a pic of the other one on my computer yet.

 

[R1V3R20NG]

"Idk which ones they are but if they're the real deal they will not be priced at $3 or $4 more like $12 and up I would guess." The Moonshiner

Chickens out here are really expensive so that isn't much of a price for me. My easter egger pullets were about 18-22 dollars each.

 

[OneMountainAcres]

Well i guess the place i go through for chickens doesn't have any true ameraucanas. i got two there. one lays teal eggs and the other brown eggs. One if them knows how to fly. Its scary. She hasn't tried to leave the yard thankfully. i knew about the egg color check thing but i didn't think it was possible for one to lay a brown egg. here is a pic of the one who flies and lays brown eggs. don't have a pic of the other one on my computer yet.

She's a very pretty girl! She almost looks like my Maple (feed store easter egger). I'm sorry that she lays brown though. Maple, when she actually does lay, lays a big green egg.

 

[The Moonshiner]

Chickens out here are really expensive so that isn't much of a price for me. My easter egger pullets were about 18-22 dollars each.

Where's out here?

 

[R1V3R20NG]

She's a very pretty girl! She almost looks like my Maple (feed store easter egger). I'm sorry that she lays brown though. Maple, when she actually does lay, lays a big green egg.

View attachment 1176699

Hey mine is named Carmel! She is smaller and less built and the bottom of the pecking order

 

[R1V3R20NG]

Where's out here?

Northern California

 

[R1V3R20NG]

Here's my flock

 

[Kiki]

What you're looking for is an Ameraucana not "Americana". Americana are just Easter Eggers and can lay any color egg.
I've heard people say there is a couple hatcheries that sale true Ameraucana.
Idk which ones they are but if they're the real deal they will not be priced at $3 or $4 more like $12 and up I would guess.
Oh and Ameraucana only lay blue eggs so if it says blue or green eggs its not an Ameraucana.

x2 everything said here.